Narrative Restraint: Reproducing the Colonial Archive in Crossing the River and Cambridge
Keywords:
Caryl Phillips; the colonial archive; obeah; the slave trade; postcolonial fictionAbstract
The colonial archive supplies Caryl Phillips with two documents of observation: the journal of an eighteenth-century slaving captain and the planter’s ethnography of obeah. Criticism has read both as pastiche, or as evidence that the novelist reduces the complexity of his sources. The novels seem to withhold the ideological confidence sustaining each source document instead of the narrative resolution. Hamilton’s ship log copies the arithmetic calculations of John Newton’s journal. Unlike Newton, however, Hamilton receives no religious repentance to ease his conscience. Emily Cartwright’s diary mimics and reproduces the typical structure and vocabulary of planter ethnographies such as the works of Mrs Carmichael and Frances Lanaghan. The framework upon which these works’ authority is grounded never arrives as a reader might expect. Critics of Phillips’s works have largely missed what one might call a “textual loan”. Specifically, Lanaghan’s note about a harmful charm buried outside a doorway clarifies an unexplained incident in Emily’s text. Whether a postcolonial novelist should mend the archive or decode it is a pressing question that has preoccupied recent scholarship in this context. In Phillips’s fiction, the colonial document is replicated and allowed to break down from within, demonstrating what Saidiya Hartman calls narrative restraint.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
Copyright (c) 2026 Oumoussa Abderrazzak

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.